先前一篇由畸變校正 App SKRWT 製作的歷代 iPhone 相機對比,讓很多人第一次直觀看到 iPhone 4s 到 6s Plus 之間的成像變化。由於作者認為首輪測試環境不足以支撐結論,於是又補做了一次。這並非推翻先前結果,而是把結論補得更完整。
全文以中英對照整理,部分段落為便於理解略作調整。
After posting “The Big iPhone Camera Comparison” I didn't felt like I gave the 6s and 6s+ the right playground to prove themselves. This time I've used a tripod and went to Rotterdam, NL with all devices for a more realistic shooting surrounding.
上一篇文章發布後,我其實一直有些糾結——我覺得當時的拍攝環境並不足以客觀反映 6s 與 6s+ 的相機實力。於是我帶上所有 iPhone 與三腳架,前往荷蘭鹿特丹,就是為了找一個更合理的場景。
注:本文所有照片均由 iPhone 拍攝,文末附有原始檔供下載。
對比測試
1,High contrast - 100% and unedited - shot using a tripod
This shot has been a tricky one. The bright white bridge and a partly cloudy sky were a good challenge to show the phones' dynamic range capabilities. The 4s image came out pretty grainy, the 5s did a decent job and starting with the 6 the images started looking better. 6+ a bit sharper than the 6 - the 6s and 6s+ winning this comparison due to the megapixel advantage and as already mentioned in the previous comparison: the new iPhones' pictures are warmer right out of the box.

iPhone 6s 拍攝|後期:SKRWT、SNAPSEED、VSCO
第一組:高對比度-100% 檢視,三腳架拍攝,未經後期
這個場景其實不好拍。斜拉橋是白色的,身後又有一大片雲層,對手機相機的動態範圍是嚴苛考驗。4s 的畫面噪點明顯,5s 尚可,從 6 開始明顯好轉,6+ 又比 6 銳利一些。6s 與 6s+ 則憑藉像素優勢拿下這一輪,也再次印證先前結論:新 iPhone 直出的色調偏暖。

2,Skin - 100% and unedited - shot using a tripod
This may be every smartphones masterclass - portraits and skin-tones. We found a good spot with nice soft light and the 6s and especially the 6s+ did the best job. Better contrast and more detailed, but the 6+ kept up very well. I don't know what happened with the 6 though, the images I shot at this spot were not on point - the 5s had no problems and lets not talk about the 4s anymore.

iPhone 6s 拍攝|後期:SKRWT、SNAPSEED、VSCO
第二輪:人像膚色-100% 檢視,三腳架拍攝,未經後期
對任何手機來說,人像與膚色還原都是必考題。這次找到了一處光線柔和的位置,6s 與 6s+ 果然沒讓人失望,對比更好、細節更完整,6+ 也咬得很緊。反倒是我沒料到 6 會失手,畫面不如預期;5s 勉強及格,4s 已經沒有討論的必要。

3,Underground - 100% and unedited - shot using a tripod
Rotterdam does have a nice underground system which was perfect for our third test. The 5s has an overall decent noise handling, but couldn't keep up with the other phones. Beginning with the 6 everything started looking crisper. It's a head to head race between the 6s+ and the 6+ at the end - the 6s can't quite match their level of detail.

iPhone 6s+ 拍攝|後期:SKRWT、SNAPSEED、VSCO
第三輪:地下場景-100% 檢視,三腳架拍攝,未經後期
鹿特丹發達的地下運輸系統為第三輪提供了合適場地。5s 的噪點控制整體不錯,但與後續機型相比仍有差距。從 6 開始畫面變得乾淨銳利,最後是 6s+ 與 6+ 的正面對決,而 6s 的細節表現沒能跟上。

4,Underground - 100% and unedited - handheld but stabilized
Hands and pants down- the 6s+ smashed everything in this shot - it took an image so much brighter and gave me a little “wow” moment. The 6s could not catch me as much as the 6+ and the 6 got the least good noise handling of the 6-series, but managed to snap a crips image.

iPhone 6s+ 拍攝|後期:SKRWT、SNAPSEED、VSCO
第四輪:地下場景-100% 檢視,手持拍攝,未經後期
這一輪 6s+ 讓我意外,照片更明亮也更好看。6 與 6+ 在夜間噪點控制上落後 6s 與 6s+,但成片依然不錯。

結論
iPhone 4s: outdated.
iPhone 5s: still working with a decent camera - reaches it's limit pretty fast when it gets a couple f-stops darker. BUT it's way smaller than the 6-series and that's a tremendous plus for me!
iPhone 6: least good one of the 6-series but still a decent choice - you'll get better images than with it's predecessors, especially in darker situations.
iPhone 6s: I really wanted you to do awesome, because the camera is the only thing that would make me switch from the 5s to a bigger phone. I have to say that 12mpx are very tempting and the better processor is helping a lot with crisp hdr images and noise reduction. I think the level of detail could be just a software thing - it will keep up with the 6+ and 6+s' sharpness with some very simple editing steps.
iPhone 6+: you really did surprise me in both tests. Clear images, good noise reduction/handling and always on point! Another thing I really liked about you has been the big screen for taking pictures - it's huge!
iPhone 6s+: the best in terms of image quality. Superb low-light and great overall performance - not to mention the extremely better image stabilization (compared to the 6s) while shooting video.
iPhone 4s:已經過時了。
iPhone 5s:勉強堪用。光線一暗幾個檔位就迅速見底,但機身比 6 系列小得多,對我而言是很大的加分。
iPhone 6:6 系列裡最弱的一款,但仍是不錯的選擇。相比前代進步明顯,暗光環境尤其有感。
iPhone 6s:我原本很期待它,因為相機是唯一能讓我從 5s 換到大螢幕的理由。1200 萬像素與更強的處理器確實誘人,HDR 更俐落、降噪也更好。我始終認為細節層次多半能靠後製補回來——就像 6+ 某些時候銳化過頭,簡單幾步就能修掉。
iPhone 6+:兩輪測試都出乎我意料。畫面清晰、降噪得宜、對焦從不跑掉。另外我實在喜歡用這麼大的螢幕取景,太過瘾了。
iPhone 6s+:成像品質最佳。低光表現出色,整體穩定;更別提影片拍攝時的防抖比 6s 明顯更好。
Now here is the thing: I did the test zooming into every image of each device while sticking my head into a 27” cinema-display. 999 out of 1000 people won't ever do the same and won't see any difference either. When I am saying that a camera is “better” it's like a photo-finish between the whole 6-series with a “s” advantage.
補充:測試過程中,我是把照片放到 27 吋螢幕上放大到 100% 檢視。絕大多數人不會這樣做,也不會察覺設備之間的差異。所以當我說某台「更好」時,那個「更好」並非天壤之別,可能只是相當於多一個 s 的程度。
You will get a good camera with the 6 and especially the 6+, but the +4mpx (more cropping freedom), way better front-camera (hello Snapchat), very good HDR mode (even with harsh backlight) and 4k video capability is a clear deal-maker if you are into photography and social media in general.
從 6 開始成像明顯改善,6+ 尤其如此。6s 與 6s+ 多出的 400 萬像素讓裁切空間更大;升級後的前置相機讓拍 Snapchat 更從容;更好的 HDR 處理連強逆光都擋得住,加上 4K 錄影,對攝影與社群用戶來說是明確的升級誘因。